In a Pennsylvania town
In nineteen twenty-one
To a miller and his wife
One day was born a son!
Stanley F. Musial!
Swinging Stan the Man!
He's the man that thrills the fans!
Swinging Stan the Man!
For those who wish to sing along they can click to play the famous tune although for obvious reasons the arranger prefers to remain anonymous.
Of course, some artistic license is allowed in any work of art. And Chuck and Bob's song - the brief excerpt quoted here for commentary and review - misses Stan's birthdate by six weeks.1
Regardless of the exact natal date, on the various "Greatest St. Louis Cardinals" lists, you'll likely find Stan Musial ranked at the top. True, the fans of Adam Wainwright, Ozzie Smith, Albert Pujols, Bob Gibson, Lou Brock, Rogers Hornsby, and of course, Jay Hanna "Dizzy" Dean may disagree. But as in matters de baseballibus just as in de gustibus, non est disputandum.
Stan the Man - his inevitable and poetical sobriquet - had an unusual style at bat. His "corkscrew stance" helped him smack line drives for base hits rather then high flys that were inevitably caught. During that span - which began in 1941 and ended in 1963 - Stan racked up 3,630 hits, 475 home runs, and 1961 runs batted in. His lifetime batting average was .331, an average most players don't even get in their best year. In Stan's first year he hit .426 - topping even Ted Williams's best year - and in his last year he hit .255, a number that a lot of good hitters achieve in their prime.
As unthinkable as it would be today with the ever shifting rosters, trades, and free agencies, Stan spent his entire 22 years in professional baseball as a Cardinal.2 Carl Yastrzemski beat Stan by one season, spending 23 years with the Boston Red Sox, as did Brooks Robinson playing for the Baltimore Orioles. But there were only two other 22 years/one team players: Mel Ott (the New York Giants) and Al Kaline (Detroit Tigers).
Footnote
Other durable players worthy of mention are George Brett (21 years at the Kansas City Royals), Walter Johnson (21 years, Washington Senators), Ted Lyons (21, Chicago White Sox), Cal Ripken Jr. (21, Baltimore Orioles), Willie Stargell (21, Pittsburgh Pirates), Luke Appling (20, Chicago White Sox), Craig Biggio (20, Houston Astros), Red Faber (20, Chicago White Sox), Tony Gwynn (20, San Diego Padres), Mel Harder (20, Cleveland Indians), Derek Jeter (20, New York Yankees), Alan Trammell (20, Detroit Tigers), Robin Yount (20, Milwaukee Brewers), Ernie Banks (19, Chicago Cubs), Dave Concepción (19, Cincinnati Reds), Charlie Gehringer (19, Detroit Tigers), Chipper Jones (19, Atlanta Braves), Barry Larkin (19, Cincinnati Reds), Yadier Molina (19, St. Louis Cardinals), Jim Palmer (19, Baltimore Orioles), Mariano Rivera (19, New York Yankees), Lou Whitaker (19, Detroit Tigers), Ted Williams (19, Boston Red Sox), Ossie Bluege (18, Washington Senators), Roberto Clemente (18, Pittsburgh Pirates), Bob Feller (18, Cleveland Indians), Clayton Kershaw (18, Los Angeles Dodgers), Ed Kranepool (18, New York Mets), Mickey Mantle (18, New York Yankees), Edgar Martínez (18, Seattle Mariners), Bid McPhee (18, Cincinnati Red Stockings/Reds), Bill Russell (18, Los Angeles Dodgers), Mike Schmidt (18, Philadelphia Phillies), Adam Wainwright (18, St. Louis Cardinals), Frank White (18, Kansas City Royals), Johnny Bench (17, Cincinnati Reds), Frankie Crosetti (17, New York Yankees), Bill Dickey (17, New York Yankees), Jim Gantner (17, Milwaukee Brewers), Lou Gehrig (17, New York Yankees), Bob Gibson (17, St. Louis Cardinals), Todd Helton (17, Colorado Rockies), Bill Mazeroski (17, Pittsburgh Pirates), Jorge Posada (17, New York Yankees), Pie Traynor (17, Pittsburgh Pirates), Joey Votto (17, Cincinnati Reds), Tommy Bridges (16, Detroit Tigers), Whitey Ford (16, New York Yankees), Stan Hack (16, Chicago Cubs), Carl Hubbell (16, New York Giants), Vern Law (16, Pittsburgh Pirates), Clyde Milan (16, Washington Senators), Pee Wee Reese (16, Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers), Jim Rice (16, Boston Red Sox), Bernie Williams (16, New York Yankees), Ryan Zimmerman (16, Washington Nationals), Jeff Bagwell (15, Houston Astros), Hooks Dauss (15, Detroit Tigers), Bill Freehan (15, Detroit Tigers), Carl Furillo (15, Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers), Félix Hernández (15, Seattle Mariners), John Hiller (15, Detroit Tigers), Travis Jackson (15, New York Giants), Bob Lemon (15, Cleveland Indians), Joe Mauer (15, Minnesota Twins), Tony Oliva (15, Minnesota Twins), Paul Splittorff (15, Kansas City Royals), Mickey Stanley (15, Detroit Tigers), Jason Varitek (15, Boston Red Sox), Roy White (15, New York Yankees), Charlie Blackmon (14, Colorado Rockies), Ryan Braun (14, Milwaukee Brewers), Bobby Doerr (14, Boston Red Sox), Don Drysdale (14, Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers), Brett Gardner (14, New York Yankees), Jim Gilliam (14, Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers), Alex Gordon (14, Kansas City Royals), Jack Graney (14, Cleveland Napoleons/Indians), Ron Guidry (14, New York Yankees), Kent Hrbek (14, Minnesota Twins), Don Mattingly (14, New York Yankees), Dustin Pedroia (14, Boston Red Sox), Tim Salmon (14, California/Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels), Bill Terry (14, New York Giants), David Wright (14, New York Mets), Bob Allison (13, Washington Senators/Minnesota Twins), Gates Brown (13, Detroit Tigers), Matt Cain (13, San Francisco Giants), Jim Davenport (13, San Francisco Giants), Joe DiMaggio (13, New York Yankees), Ryan Howard (13, Philadelphia Phillies), Sam Leever (13, Pittsburgh Pirates), Pepper Martin (13, St. Louis Cardinals), Scott McGregor (13, Baltimore Orioles), Otto Miller (13, Brooklyn Superbas/Dodgers/Robins), Ron Oester (13, Cincinnati Reds), Rico Petrocelli (13, Boston Red Sox), Phil Rizzuto (13, New York Yankees), Steve Rogers (13, Montreal Expos), Eddie Rommel (13, Philadelphia Athletics), Hal Schumacher (13, New York Giants), Mike Scioscia (13, Los Angeles Dodgers), Sibby Sisti (13, Boston Bees/Braves/Milwaukee Braves), Bob Stanley (13, Boston Red Sox), Stephen Strasburg (13, Washington Nationals), Pete Suder (13, Philadelphia Athletics/Kansas City Athletics), Mike Tiernan (13, New York Giants), Bruce Benedict (12, Atlanta Braves), Randy Bush (12, Minnesota Twins), Earle Combs (12, New York Yankees), Gary DiSarcina (12, California/Anaheim Angels), Carl Erskine (12, Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers), Andre Ethier (12, Los Angeles Dodgers), Dick Green (12, Kansas City/Oakland Athletics), Mike Greenwell (12, Boston Red Sox), Ron Hodges (12, New York Mets), Ron Karkovice (12, Chicago White Sox), Sandy Koufax (12, Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers), Dennis Leonard (12, Kansas City Royals), Jo-Jo Moore (12, New York Giants), Tom Pagnozzi (12, St. Louis Cardinals), Glen Perkins (12, Minnesota Twins), Buster Posey (12, San Francisco Giants), Kirby Puckett (12, Minnesota Twins), Brad Radke (12, Minnesota Twins), Bobby Richardson (12, New York Yankees), Mario Soto (12, Cincinnati Reds), Cecil Travis (12, Washington Senators), Gene Alley (11, Pittsburgh Pirates), Carson Bigbee (11, Pittsburgh Pirates), Spud Chandler (11, New York Yankees), Larry Christenson (11, Philadelphia Phillies), Dom DiMaggio (11, Boston Red Sox), Tim Flannery (11, San Diego Padres), Tommy Henrich (11, New York Yankees), Bobby Higginson (11, Detroit Tigers), Fred Hutchinson (11, Detroit Tigers), Arndt Jorgens (11, New York Yankees), Buddy Lewis (11, Washington Senators), Terry Moore (11, St. Louis Cardinals), Guy Morton (11, Cleveland Napoleons/Indians), Thurman Munson (11, New York Yankees), Kyle Seager (11, Seattle Mariners), Mel Stottlemyre (11, New York Yankees), Robby Thompson (11, San Francisco Giants), Bill Wegman (11, Milwaukee Brewers), Wes Westrum (11, New York Giants), Joe Astroth (10, Philadelphia Athletics/Kansas City Athletics), Jerry Augustine (10, Milwaukee Brewers), Ray Blades (10, St. Louis Cardinals), Steve Blass (10, Pittsburgh Pirates), Al Brazle (10, St. Louis Cardinals), Roy Campanella (10, Brooklyn Dodgers), Bill Carrigan (10, Boston Americans/Red Sox), Joe Collins (10, New York Yankees), John Danks (10, Chicago White Sox), Harry Danning (10, New York Giants), Rich Dauer (10, Baltimore Orioles), Dick Fowler (10, Philadelphia Athletics), Scott Garrelts (10, San Francisco Giants), Patsy Gharrity (10, Washington Senators), Jake Gibbs (10, New York Yankees), Orval Grove (10, Chicago White Sox), Terry Harmon (10, Philadelphia Phillies), Chris Hoiles (10, Baltimore Orioles), Ray Kremer (10, Pittsburgh Pirates), Gil McDougald (10, New York Yankees), Bob Miller (10, Philadelphia Phillies), Bob Montgomery (10, Boston Red Sox), Bob Moose (10, Pittsburgh Pirates), Johnny Mostil (10, Chicago White Sox), Pat Mullin (10, Detroit Tigers), Mike Norris (10, Oakland Athletics), Mel Parnell (10, Boston Red Sox), Biff Pocoroba (10, Atlanta Braves), J. R. Richard (10, Houston Astros), Jackie Robinson (10, Brooklyn Dodgers), Red Rolfe (10, New York Yankees), Al Rosen (10, Cleveland Indians), Nap Rucker (10, Brooklyn Superbas/Dodgers/Robins), Scot Shields (10, Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels), Vic Sorrell (10, Detroit Tigers), Mike Squires (10, Chicago White Sox), Lee Tannehill (10, Chicago White Stockings/White Sox), Chris Tillman (10, Baltimore Orioles), John Wathan (10, Kansas City Royals), Larry Woodall (10, Detroit Tigers), and Ross Youngs (10, New York Giants).
On the other end of the spectrum is Jimmy Boyle of the New York Giants. Jimmy was a catcher and he debuted in the majors on June 20, 1926. He was sent in to play at the beginning of the 9th Inning in a game against Pittsburgh. But he never even got a chance to bat as the three outs pitched by Vic Aldrige won the game for Pittsburgh.
Evidently Jimmy decided baseball was not for him and he asked the Giants' manager, John McGraw, to be released.
During his tenure on the team Stan played in every World Series where the Cardinals landed. All in all the Cardinals have played in the World Series 23 times, the first in 1926. Their 1942 Series was Stan's first and he was in 12 more contests. Of those three - 1942, 1944, and 1945 - the Cardinals won. Alas, the Cards have never had such a cluster of wins since and their last appearance in a World Series was lamentably in 2011.
Stan was selected for 24 All Star games and naturally he was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame on the first ballot. That was only six years after he retired. Out of 247 Hall of Famers elected in the 20th Century, only 35 were first ballot selections.
One characteristic of Stan was a genial personality and although he may have disagreed with a call here and there, he was never ejected from a game. After all it's not every baseball player who has a catchy tune written about them. Certainly you don't hear songs like:
Billy Martin is the man
Who argues with the umps!
No matter what play they call
He always says they're chumps!
But of course Billy was in a class by himself.
A Class by Himself
(Click to zoom in and out.)
References and Further Reading
Musial: From Stash to Stan the Man, James Giglio, University of Missouri Press, 2001.
"Stan Musial", Baseball Reference.
"Baseball Hall of Fame Alphabetical List", Baseball Almanac.
"The 20 Greatest St. Louis Cardinals of All-Time", Baseball Scholar.